Credit Scores vs. Insurance Scores: What They Mean for Your Premiums

Credit Scores vs Insurance Scores

Why Insurance Scores Are Sparking New Trends in Telematics Programs

Ever wonder how your insurance score affects your premiums? Or thought about switching to one of those telematics programs you’ve been hearing about? You’re not alone. Lately, a curious trend has emerged in the insurance world. Consumers with low insurance scores are back to shopping around for better deals after a lull that began in 2021. What’s driving the change, and how could programs like State Farm’s Drive Safe & Save or Progressive’s Snapshot shake things up even more?

Spoiler alert: a lot’s going on, and it could mean an influx of telematics adopters.

What Are Insurance Scores, and Why Do They Matter?

Before we go any further, what even are insurance scores? Think of them as credit scores for your insurance, designed to predict how likely you are to file a claim. They’re based on your credit history, and like your FICO score, a high number means fewer financial headaches for you. A low number? Higher premiums.

Here’s the thing, though—not all states allow this. California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan don’t think it’s fair to link premiums to your credit history. That means no insurance score calculations there. If you live in one of these states and have a not-so-great credit record, congratulations, you’re probably getting a better deal than you would elsewhere.

For everyone else, insurance scores still matter. And if yours is on the lower end, you’re likely among the millions who’ve been browsing for new policies lately.

Why Are Lower-Score Shoppers Making Moves Now?

It’s a shift! Post-2021, we didn’t see much activity from consumers on the low-end of the insurance score spectrum. But since then? Shopping’s back on the rise.

Why now? Several factors are at play.

  1. Rate hikes. Insurers are ramping up premiums for riskier profiles again, and lower insurance scores sit squarely in that zone. If your renewal notice made you spill your coffee, you’re not alone.
  2. Inflation woes. Groceries cost a fortune, and wages aren’t exactly soaring. It only makes sense that folks are comparison shopping to save wherever they can.
  3. It’s easier to compare. Thanks to online tools, finding better rates is pretty simple these days. A few clicks, and boom, you’ve got options.

FAQ: Aren’t consumers with low scores always price-sensitive?
Usually, yes! But during the height of the pandemic, shopping slowed, partly because insurers were offering discounts or premium relief. Those days are over, and bills are climbing again.Telematics

Enter Telematics or Usage-Based Insurance

Here’s where it gets interesting. While shopping for lower premiums, more consumers are turning to telematics. These programs track your driving habits through an app or plug-in device, rewarding you for safe driving with discounts.

Think about it. If you’re stuck with a high premium due to a low insurance score, a telematics program could save you big-time by evaluating how you actually drive—not just what’s on your credit report.

The Top Most Popular Telematics Programs

1. State Farm’s Drive Safe & Save
This is the frontrunner in telematics. Why? It’s super accessible, widely available, and rewards mileage-conscious drivers. Tracking is easy with their app or connected car devices, and you can save up to 30%. No wonder it’s one of the most popular programs out there. (Not to mention, State Farm has one heck of a reputation.)

2. Progressive’s Snapshot
Ever heard of Snapshot? It’s been around a while and remains a favorite. They’ll evaluate your driving for about six months, looking at factors like time of day and braking habits. Safe drivers get up to 30% off their premium. A few of my friends have used this program. One of them saved $200 in her first year, just by drastically cutting back on late-night drives.

3. USAA’s SafePilot
Tailored for military families, SafePilot rewards precision driving. It’s a great way for eligible families to score savings while sticking to careful habits.

What’s cool about these programs is how they meet drivers where they are. If you’re not credit-score-perfect but know you’re a safe driver, this tech shifts the focus to actual behaviors.

FAQ: What if I’m a bad driver? Will telematics make my rates go up?
It depends. Some programs only apply discounts (like State Farm), while others, like Progressive’s Snapshot, might increase rates if risky driving is detected. Always check the fine print!

The Tipping Point for Telematics

We’re at a tipping point. Remember earlier when we talked about consumers shopping again? Many are making the leap to telematics as part of their insurance hunt. After all, these programs feel fairer. Haven’t we all thought, “Why should someone in the same zip code pay less if I’m driving more carefully?” Telematics answers that.

Take these stats:

  • The number of U.S. telematics policies hit 17.9 million in 2023, and it’s expected to reach 26.3 million by 2028.
  • Globally, the usage-based insurance market is projected to grow 11.34% annually, reaching $74.53 billion by 2030.

What does that tell you? People want control over their costs.

Relatable Example Alert

When my cousin, a gig worker, switched to Nationwide’s SmartRide program, he was skeptical. Using an app to track his driving? Felt invasive. But after the first month, he saw his projected discount climb to 30%. Turns out avoiding that daily late-night delivery run saved him a ton.

The Case for Giving Telematics a ShotFamily Emergency Organizer - Free from Live Insurance News

Still not sure if telematics is for you? Think about this.
Does your insurance score haunt you?
Do you drive safely?
Is saving money as easy as, say, checking your phone?

If you answered “yes” to any of those, telematics could be for you. For safe drivers, it rewards habits rather than penalizing circumstances. And hey, with low sign-up risks (most programs offer free apps or brief trial periods), what have you got to lose?

Final FAQ for the Road

Will telematics work with my old car?
Yes! Most programs use either a smartphone app or tiny plug-in devices compatible with cars made after 1996.

Do programs penalize every late-night trip?
Not really. One late-night run to McDonald’s won’t tank your rate. They’re looking for patterns, not one-offs.

Wrap Up

The insurance world is shifting. Shopping is up, telematics programs are thriving, and drivers are taking control of their premiums. For anyone haunted by a low insurance score or just looking for more fairness, options like State Farm’s Drive Safe & Save and Progressive’s Snapshot are hard to ignore.

Maybe it’s time to ask yourself, “Is this the year I take the telematics plunge?” Big savings could just be a drive away.

how much do you know

How Much Do You Really Know About Insurance Myths?

Think you can spot fact from fiction when it comes to wacky insurance myths? From realistic situations to out of this world coverage, this quiz will put your myth-busting skills to the test. Buckle up (yes, it’s insured) and see if you’re ready to conquer the world of absurd policies!

1 / 7

True or False: Red cars cost more to insure.

are red cars more to insure

2 / 7

Which of these incidents is NOT typically covered by comprehensive auto insurance?

driving underwater

3 / 7

Does renters insurance cover your roommate’s belongings?

roommates insurance

4 / 7

If someone else drives your car and gets into an accident, whose insurance pays first?

auto insurance myths

5 / 7

Does homeowners insurance cover damage caused by floods?

flood insurance

6 / 7

Do all drivers in a household need to be listed on an auto insurance policy?

drivers in home

7 / 7

What does Fantasy Football Insurance protect you against? And yes, there is such a thing.

fantasy football insurance

Your score is

The average score is 67%

0%

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.